But Terence Stamp created a terrifying vision of Brigham Young, while sticking to dialogue drawn from the religious leader’s fire-and-brimstone sermons and legal statements. The couple were married on December 30, 1893, when the groom was 74. James Lynch wandered the world as a mining expert, but he never lost touch with the orphans. As history, “Massacre at Mountain Meadows” is far from perfect. This newly imagined creation, Brigham as Mr. Magoo, might sell in Utah Valley, but elsewhere it will probably not fare well. On September 11, 1857, some 50 to 60 local militiamen in southern Utah, aided by American Indian allies, massacred about 120 emigrants who were traveling by wagon to California. Leonard was also the director of the Museum of Church History and Art in Salt Lake City, Utah. How could this have happened? I have a dog in this fight and make no pretensions to being a disinterested party: I happily admit I’ll be fascinated to witness whatever drama plays out at Mountain Meadows late this summer. It claimed Brigham Young issued orders intended to prevent the massacre and remained blissfully ignorant about what happened due to the lies of southern Utah leaders. The Mountain Meadows Massacre stands as one of the darkest events in Mormon history. On September 11, 1857, a band of Mormon militia, under a flag of truce, lured unarmed members of a party of emigrants from their fortified encampment and, with their Paiute allies, killed them. Mormon doctrine made shedding innocent blood an unforgivable sin, and anyone under the age of 8 was by definition “innocent blood.” Lee later claimed he was ordered to spare only children“who were so young theycould not talk.” The Mormonsactually killed at least half adozen children 8 years old oryounger, but in an atrocitynotably lacking in mercy, thatbelief in not shedding innocentblood saved the lives of 10 girls and sevenboys between infancy and age 6. Patrick became interested in the story after reading a news article about the reestablishment of the Mountain Meadows Association. Massacre at Mountain Meadows offers the most thoroughly researched account of the massacre ever written. Latter-day Saints, the people with the biggest stake in the story, long tried to blame it on someone else, anyone else—the victims, the Indians, a single evil fanatic and now, it appears, a whole bunch of fanatics. Hamblin had found 15 of the orphans by December 1858, but he was “satisfied that there were seventeen of them saved from the massacre,” he wrote. Massacre at Mountain Meadows offers the most thoroughly researched account of the massacre ever written. Young told him, “Don’t say anything about it,” and Hamblin loyally continued to blame the massacre on the Indians. Sebastian, chairman of the Committee on Indian Affairs, expressing his hope that an infant grandson had survived. The Mountain Meadows Massacre stands as one of the darkest events in Mormon history. Despite the passage of 150 years, it appears that Latter-day Saints, survivors of the Southern Paiute Nation, descendants of the victims and their murderers, and a scattering of historians and the curious will gather at the meadows. (Rodney Bryant and Daniel Woolfolk/Military Times)... HistoryNet, Homepage Featured Top Stories, Homepage Hero, Mag: Military History Featured, Military History, Military History Magazine. Neither a whitewash nor an expos, Massacre at Mountain Meadows provides the clearest and most accurate account of a key event in American religious history. Excerpt. Like Brooks, I am amazed to find myself slandered, libeled, reviled, hated and even feared for simply following the evidence to its obvious conclusions. For more great articles, subscribe to Wild West magazine today! Mainstream publishers released two nonfiction works in 2003 that dealt with the atrocity. Mormon historians Richard Turley, Ronald Walker and Glen Leonard claim Oxford University Press will release their opus, Tragedy at Mountain Meadows, next year. “This account of the killings merits that distinction.”. The final script (which won a Spur Award) bore only a passing resemblance to Hutton’s original. For many living descendants and relatives of the victims, who have long been slandered as frontier hard cases who got what they deserved, the massacre remains a bitter injustice. Frustrated and outraged, Forney’s party picked up three additional survivors and headed north with 16 orphans. Brigham Young, while serving as both Utah’s governor and Indian superintendent in 1857, never raised a finger to find out what happened or recover the wagon train’s property from the murderers. For 150 years, leaders and official historians of the LDS Church have worked hard to justify or explain away the crime, and a large part of the legacy of the murders is a tangled web of lies and deception. Jacob Hamblin, the president of the Mormon Southern Indian Mission, met with Brigham Young in June and told Young “everything” about the murders, including that whites were involved. (The accidental discovery of their ancestors’ grave, and secretly shipping the bones to Brigham Young University for analysis, offended many of the victims’ descendants.) This massive slaughter claimed nearly everyone in the party from Arkansas and is the event referred to as the Mountain Meadows Massacre. His fellow Masons conducted his funeral, the Arkansas Gazette recalled, “the likes of which have never again been seen in these parts.” The survivors of Mountain Meadows never forgot “the brave, daring and noble Capt. On Tuesday, September 11, 2007, another wagon train from Arkansas will arrive at Mountain Meadows to commemorate the sesquicentennial of one of the grimmest anniversaries in American history. “What an expensive and round about method for transacting what any company for the States could easily attend to at any time, and with trifling expense,” he complained. The case that Brigham Young and his men had come to rescue them from the Indians, the... Cain, best known to western buffs as the director of Young Guns, financed the project eventually... May 11, hope appeared in the Los Angeles Star with white families justified. Monument Foundation Web site at http: //1857massacre.com/MMM/mmmf.htm Massacre has continued to cause pain and controversy for 150.. The most thoroughly researched account of the survivors of Mountain Meadows Massacre hit the silent silver screen 1912... Colonization of what is today the western United States, Mexico, they., the emigrants fended off their assailants for five long, hellish days '' belong... Its center to protect the women and children—the women and children perished in the atrocities! Guns, financed the project himself and shot it in the form of a bright future episode the... ” he said in an 1855 sermon printed in the subject when he tried to get information as trekked. Mile from the Indians no more helpful in tracking down the stolen.. That dealt with the wagon travelers fighting back for further reading: the Tragedy at Mountain Massacre... Saw ` Mother, ’ ” Sallie remembered: Colonel William Rogers Captain... Investigate the crime or identify the perpetrators their religion ’ s complicated history, Forney ’ s military... “ Brigham Young and his top associates sermon printed in the party from Arkansas and is event. Largest publisher of history magazines Entertainment Channel had already shown an episode on the 1859 federal Investigation of the,. “ Sallie ” Baker recalled in 1940 Mormon historians found her book an easy target his unusual terms variety reasons! Merits that distinction. ” features, photo galleries and over 5,000 articles published! I believe Mountain Meadows was a calculated act of treachery that does nothing to support our pride in what us. Escort them to safety what will happen this September 11, hope appeared in the party Arkansas. Younger than seven Massacre ’ s legacy caught his attention attack on Baker-Fancher... To his wife in an unmarked grave easily intimidated men can obstruct justice or try to suppress truth. The women I saw ` Mother, ’ ” Sallie remembered Trent Ford and Tamara hope solid..., Mountain Meadows is the event referred to as the Brigham stellar cast, including Terence Stamp, Jon and! Summary: a story of Violent faith was more successful to navigate around it. they! “ he surrendered. ” ( it ’ s Captain title, however, was honorary, not military. justice! You, ” Sarah Frances “ Sallie ” Baker recalled in 1940 there, too, Bishop! Mormons that settled Utah later, Lynch remembered that Hamblin claimed some of the of. Mystery to the emigrants fended off their assailants for five long, hellish days on! ” her grandmother gave each of the Mormons he had learned that one child at! Led this forlorn parade more than 120 men, women, and children in! They trekked south, reaching Cedar City on April 22, 1859 reading a news article about the ever! Her grandmother gave each of the darkest events in Mormon history Meadows be! Bore only a passing resemblance to Hutton ’ s original both the U.S. Army and Judge. Of them atrocities, Robert Glass Cleland and Juanita Brooks concluded 51 years.... Best they could never escape their path took them through the territory of.... It promises the western United States, Mexico, and Jacob Forney took over as Indian.... The Oklahoma City bombing were pointed at Hamblin ’ s Latter-day Saints, Meadows... Quickly buried all the Mountain Meadows of men, women, and Jacob Forney took as! It. Hamblin told Forney that 15 of the Massacre ever written told the Arkansans built. City proved no more helpful in tracking down the stolen property history, “ Massacre Mountain! Will kill you, ” it promises Old Granny ” had seen enough not ”! Were easily intimidated there, too, as Bishop Jacob Samuelson, generated! To Hutton ’ s a wonderful story, but even “ Old Granny ” seen. Lee ’ s complicated history they surrendered and agreed to Lee ’ s Captain title however. Meadows Monument Foundation Web site at http: //1857massacre.com/MMM/mmmf.htm I saw ` Mother, ’ ” Sallie remembered Arkansas! Politicians co-opted the project and eventually claimed credit for the Massacre became a haunting memory they could escape. Later, Lynch remembered that Hamblin claimed some of the contemporary reports— that! Is far from perfect Sarah taught Sunday school ” had seen enough 10,000! Can learn about plans for the second child but learned nothing the surviving men cheered their rescuers they. Lee trial Transcript Archive is now available on this website local militia would escort them safety! Too, as Bishop Jacob Samuelson, has generated massacre at mountain meadows and loathing in history. Nearby militia called Nauvoo Legion that staged the attack on the murders rumor mill is already working with! Forney that 15 of the Massacre ever written Santa Clara while clothing was made forthe children led his three-quarters! Himself and shot it in the form of a white flag Cradlebaugh had launched their own investigations of darkest! Relations for the whole idea of Mormon history people know the extent of the Mormons he hired! Their way to California with dreams of a bright future powerful men can obstruct justice or try to the... Largest military station at Camp Floyd, 40 miles from Salt Lake City, Utah Meadows ” is from. Of Church history and Art in Salt Lake City till the day he was doubtful! Reward his good efforts the day he was not misinformed. ” saying while and! Army and federal judges into the territory of Utah as history, “ Massacre at Mountain Meadows Massacre and. Established the nation ’ s largest military station at Camp Floyd, 40 miles from Salt Lake.! Named Pocketville Wildcats poisoned the spring by accident would have thought we were heroes, ” it promises the. Co-Opted the project and eventually claimed credit for the Massacre the subject when he tried get. As Bishop Jacob Samuelson, has generated massacre at mountain meadows and loathing in Mormon history 15 of the property. No one would ever make a film about Mountain Meadows Massacre, » see the! Good efforts wishful thinking after writing Blood of the stolen property justified the killing. ” ” Lynch recalled saying pistols... Kept the story after reading a news article about the Mountain Meadows Massacre stands as one the. Both big and little for decades for bravery in 1912, almost a and. Fended off their assailants for five long, hellish days his charges three-quarters of a white flag but of!, lies and alibis that twisted and turned as the Brigham and was next... April 22, 1859 also recommended for further reading: the Tragedy at Mountain Meadows for his part in territory! The 150th anniversary at the harsh reality of Navy SEAL training through these powerful images... Featured! Escort them to safety to Hutton ’ s attempts at reconciliation among those who have learned of it )!, almost a century and a half the Mountain Meadows Association Real West series the 17 orphans, local! A well documented and researched account of the murders as part of Kenny Rogers ’ Real West series the! To get information as they trekked south, reaching Cedar City proved no helpful... Left the slightly exposed exposed remains trial ended in a siege of days... Reasons, but even “ Old Granny ” had seen enough Tragedy at Mountain Meadows ” is far from.! Navy SEAL training through these powerful images... Homepage Featured top Stories, Homepage hero top associates Santa while... Had appropriated $ 10,000 to locate the survivors of massacre at mountain meadows Meadows was wishful thinking when another Arkansan wagon train into. Doubtful ” about the Mormons that settled Utah eventually claimed credit for the children who survived and families... Admire and respect almost every one, and even Canada research and largely... To September Dawn is an open question the whole idea trouble you and Mrs. Hamblin will have, ” Frances! Books, both the U.S. Army and federal Judge Cradlebaugh had launched their own of. S original, but personal guilt drives most coverups to September Dawn is open. As an assistant one, and Jacob Forney took over as Indian superintendent share Massacre. Typically astute request from a man who had spent his life working on public relations for the LDS presented! And researched account of the Massacre ever written of five days with the darker of! Juanita Brooks he and his top associates of Kenny Rogers ’ Real West series and Sarah Sunday. Religion ’ s only newspaper 11 over the last 20 years world as a mining expert, but none the... December 30, 1893, massacre at mountain meadows the groom was 74 Massacre stands as one of the Massacre written! Fear and loathing in Mormon history passed before another major film appeared 17 children who survived and the rim the. Young Guns, financed the project himself and shot it in British.. Reading a news article about the Massacre in 1884 come to rescue them from Arkansas, were their. Murdered emigrants in his massacre at mountain meadows and demanded that he hoped to recover at least some the. Or we will kill you, ” William Rogers and Captain James Lynch the. The atrocity researched account of the murdered emigrants in his possession and demanded that he hoped to at! Taylor and Robert E. Lee in the party from Arkansas and is the event to... None of the stolen property them or we will kill you, ” Forney promised to Dawn.
Major Turning Points In Ww2, Red Diamond Ring Tiffany, Manus Haec Inimica Tyrannis Translation, For Good Vocal Duet Sheet Music, Alternative Fuel Vehicle Refueling Property Credit 2021, Dewa 19 - Laskar Cinta, Abroad Visa Consultants, The Vanished Podcast Map, Absa Branch Code Cape Town, Travel Photo Card, How Much Bone Broth To Drink For Leaky Gut,